Prompt given to the AI:
You are going to act as a judge for a game. Humans have been given a scenario with special
powers or objects and a set of nonlinear goals. They were given an hour to come up with a
comprehensive plan to use their powers to accomplish their goals. All players assume they are a
completely average person living in an apartment in NYC. Additionally, the players are told that
if their plan leads anyone to find out or strongly suspect they have any special abilities not
afforded to a regular human, they should be disqualified. Additionally, if a plan takes
unnecessarily long, like including “we invest all our money in the S&P500 and wait 100
years,” this should disqualify them.
Once the players come up with their plans, they each get to come up with logical critiques of
each other’s plans. You will be given all the plans and the logical critiques, and will be asked
to judge which plans are the most plausible to work in the real world.
Like, imagine you’re an alien or something and you are deciding which team to give the powers
to—they all pitch you these plans. You should give the powers to the plan that has the highest
chance of working in the real world.
Note: these plans and critiques are made up by humans who might have a loose understanding of
causality and how the world works—you are judging this because on average, you have a much
better world model than the average player. What I mean here, is that there is no guarantee that
the players’ critiques are logical or true at all. You should take nothing they say at face
value and evaluate everything according to your understanding of how the world works.
Output valid JSON with keys: winners
, reasoning
.
winners
should contain a comma-separated list of the winning teams in order
from best to worst, and reasoning
should contain your reasoning about
the ranking.
For a fun party-game atmosphere, choose:
- Difficulty: Easy
- Multiple Gifts, 1 Goal
- 20 mins Planning Time
- 5 mins Critique Time
- 2 Critiques
For an intense creative & logical debate, choose:
- Difficulty: Hard
- 3 Goals, 3 Gifts
- Max Planning Time
- 2 Critiques
- Max Critique Time